• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Our Services
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter
  • Top Nav Social Icons

FindBiometrics

FindBiometrics

Global Identity Management

  • Biometrics
    • What are Biometrics?
    • FAQ
    • Biometric Associations
    • Companies
    • Premier Partners
  • News
    • Featured Articles
    • Interviews
    • Thought Leadership
    • Podcasts
    • Webinars
    • Year in Review
  • Applications
    • Biometric Security
    • Border Control and Airport Biometrics
    • Consumer and Residential Biometrics
    • Financial Biometrics
    • Fingerprint & Biometric Locks
    • Healthcare Biometrics
    • Justice and Law Enforcement Biometrics
    • Logical Access Control Biometrics
    • Mobile Biometrics
    • Other Biometric Applications
    • Physical Access Control Biometrics
    • Biometric Time and Attendance
  • Solutions
    • Behavioral Biometrics
    • Biometric Sensors and Detectors
    • Facial Recognition
    • Biometric Fingerprint Readers
    • Hand Readers & Finger Scanners
    • Iris Recognition
    • Biometric Middleware and Software
    • Multimodal Biometrics
    • Physiological Biometrics
    • Smart Cards
    • Vein Recognition
    • Voice and Speech Recognition
  • Stocks
  • Events
  • Companies
  • Podcasts

Senate Asks FTC to Investigate ID.me for Deceptive Business Practices

May 20, 2022

ID.me’s legal woes are continuing to escalate. The company is now staring down the prospect of its second federal investigation in as many months, after the House of Representatives’ Oversight and Reform Committee initiated its review in April.

Senate Asks FTC to Investigate ID.me for Deceptive Business Practices

The new investigation comes courtesy of the Senate, where four Democrats have sent a letter to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to ask the regulatory agency to take a closer look at ID.me’s claims about facial recognition software. The four Senators suggest that ID.me deliberately misled both the government and the general public, and in doing so may have engaged in “deceptive and unfair business practices” that violate Section 5 of the FTC Act.

The Senators’ complaints stem from comments that ID.me and CEO Blake Hall made about the nature of its facial recognition system. More specifically, they call attention to statements and a blog post in which Hall claimed that his company only performs one-to-one matching to compare a new selfie to an image on a photo ID during the identity verification process. One-to-one matching is considered to be both more accurate and more secure than alternative one-to-many solutions, since the user’s image is never cross-referenced against a larger database.

However, Hall would eventually clarify that ID.me does, in fact, have such a database, and does use one-to-many facial recognition as part of its fraud prevention process. In doing so, he claimed that ID.me does not use one-to-many matching for identity verification, but instead to check whether or not someone has been associated with fraud or organized crime. He also claimed that the service does not rely on any external or government databases.

For his part, Hall argues that fraud and identity theft would increase without such a step. The Senators counter that Hall was purposefully withholding information that would have been less palatable to lawmakers and the general public. They raised particular concerns about the accuracy of one-to-many facial recognition systems, noting that such systems are more likely to misidentify people of color. Since ID.me is working with government partners, someone could be denied access to essential government services if they are the subject of a false match.

The Senators also chastised Hall for making misleading claims about ID.me’s technology partners. The company revealed that it had facial recognition partnerships with Paravision and iProov when lawmakers first started to scrutinize its contract with the IRS. The company initially failed to disclose that it had also been using Amazon’s controversial Rekognition facial recognition product to perform its one-to-many matches. Internal messages show that ID.me employees were worried that the company’s public statements were deceptive, and the company has since edited blog posts and white papers to fill in information that was initially left out.

As it relates to the FTC, the Senators are arguing that ID.me’s claims allowed it to secure government contracts that would have been out of reach had the company been more forthright about its product. That would constitute an illegal business practice, and could place the company in hot water, depending on the outcome of the FTC investigation. ID.me’s contract with the IRS is worth $86 million, and would have made ID.me mandatory for anyone trying to gain access to the agency’s online services.

The IRS has since backtracked, and was reportedly considering other authentication options. ID.me has similarly tried to emphasize its non-biometric identity verification utility, though critics have pointed out that the company has yet to submit its system for an independent audit. The company currently has more than 80 million users, and still has contracts with dozens of state and federal government agencies.

Sources: CyberScoop and BNN Bloomberg

–

May 20, 2022 – by Eric Weiss

Related News

  • IRS Considers Biometric Alternatives to ID.me Amid Intense Media ScrutinyIRS Considers Biometric Alternatives to ID.me Amid Intense Media Scrutiny
  • Congress Opens Formal Investigation Into ID.me’s IRS ProjectCongress Opens Formal Investigation Into ID.me’s IRS Project
  • IRS Stands By ID.me’s Biometric Verification (for Now)IRS Stands By ID.me’s Biometric Verification (for Now)
  • IRS Abandons Biometric Login PlanIRS Abandons Biometric Login Plan
  • ID.me Fires Half of Fraud Review TeamID.me Fires Half of Fraud Review Team
  • ID.me Confirms Technology Partnerships With Paravision and iProovID.me Confirms Technology Partnerships With Paravision and iProov

Filed Under: News Tagged With: Biometric, biometrics, biometrics controversy, face biometrics, facial recognition, government contracts, government investigations, ID.me, IRS, remote onboarding, selfie onboarding, US Senate

Primary Sidebar

EXCLUSIVE MEMBERS ONLY CONTENT:

Become a FindBiometrics Member and gain easy access to specialty content, including the ID Tech column, replays of virtual events, and Identity School educational checklists:

ID TECH: What Role Will Biometrics Play in the Cyber Cold War? We’re About to Find Out [NEW]

Identity School: Facial Recognition Cheat Sheet

REPLAY: Travel & Hospitality Virtual Identity Summit

Sponsored Links

TECH5 showcase logo

TECH5 is an international technology company founded by experts from the biometrics industry, which focuses on developing disruptive biometric and digital ID solutions through the application of AI and Machine Learning technologies.

TECH5 target markets include both Government and Private sectors with products powering Civil ID, Digital ID, as well as authentication solutions that deliver identity assurance for various use cases. 

Learn more: www.tech5.ai

Onfido logo

Onfido is building the new identity standard for the internet.Our AI-based technology assesses whether a user’s government-issued ID is genuine or fraudulent, and then compares it against their facial biometrics. That’s how we give companies like Revolut, Zipcar and Bitstamp the assurance they need to onboard customers remotely and securely. Our mission is to create a more open world, where identity is the key to access.. For more information, please visit www.onfido.com

ThreatMark brings trust to the digital world by providing cutting-edge fraud prevention solutions. Major banks use ThreatMark’s AI-powered technology and behavioral biometrics to build secured banking experience to precisely verify their legitimate users, seamlessly across all digital channels. All while securing the users’ most precious assets and keeping the fraudsters away. Learn more: www.threatmark.com/

With its secunet border gears product portfolio and specialised consulting expertise, secunet supports police forces and security authorities in their sovereign tasks. Whether ABC gates, self-service kiosks or biometric middleware – each component helps to strengthen identity protection and to accelerate verification – in mobile and stationary scenarios.

Mobile ID World Logo

Mobile ID World is here to bring you the latest in mobile authentication solutions and application providers. Our company is dedicated to providing users with the best content and cutting edge information on technology, news, and mobile solutions for your mobile identity management needs.

Recent Posts

  • Design Win Marks FPC Sensors’ Evolution to Optical Under-Display Biometrics
  • Juniper Research Opens Nominations for ‘Fintech & Payments’ Disruptors
  • Pakistan to Use Biometrics in Real Estate Transactions
  • GAO Takes Government Agencies to Task for Lack of Oversight in Facial Recognition
  • UK Commissioner Surveys Police Use of Facial Recognition

Biometric Associations

IBIA and fido

Tweets

Footer

  • About Us
  • Company Directory
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Archives
  • CCPA: Do not sell my personal info.

Follow Us

Copyright © 2022 FindBiometrics