• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Our Services
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter
  • Top Nav Social Icons

FindBiometrics

FindBiometrics

Global Identity Management

  • Biometrics
    • What are Biometrics?
    • FAQ
    • Biometric Associations
    • Companies
    • Premier Partners
  • News
    • Featured Articles
    • Interviews
    • Thought Leadership
    • Podcasts
    • Webinars
    • Year in Review
  • Applications
    • Biometric Security
    • Border Control and Airport Biometrics
    • Consumer and Residential Biometrics
    • Financial Biometrics
    • Fingerprint & Biometric Locks
    • Healthcare Biometrics
    • Justice and Law Enforcement Biometrics
    • Logical Access Control Biometrics
    • Mobile Biometrics
    • Other Biometric Applications
    • Physical Access Control Biometrics
    • Biometric Time and Attendance
  • Solutions
    • Behavioral Biometrics
    • Biometric Sensors and Detectors
    • Facial Recognition
    • Biometric Fingerprint Readers
    • Hand Readers & Finger Scanners
    • Iris Recognition
    • Biometric Middleware and Software
    • Multimodal Biometrics
    • Physiological Biometrics
    • Smart Cards
    • Vein Recognition
    • Voice and Speech Recognition
  • Stocks
  • Events
  • Companies
  • Podcasts

Judge Freezes Facebook’s BIPA Settlement, Suggesting Too Much Lenience

June 8, 2020

A $550 million dollar settlement negotiated by Facebook has been put on hold by U.S. District Judge James Donato until lawyers explain to him why the amount is only a fraction of what the damages could be under the Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA) which Facebook is said to have violated.

Judge Freezes Facebook's BIPA Settlement, Suggesting Too Much Lenience

The class-action suit — which was filed by lead plaintiff Nimesh Patel in 2015 — alleges that Facebook began mapping users’ faces in 2011 for a feature that recognizes individuals in photos and suggests tags for them.

Under the BIPA, capturing and/or storing an individual’s biometric data (in this case face prints) without the written consent of the individual is illegal in the state of Illinois, and upon conviction carries a fine of $1,000 per negligent infraction, and $5,000 for each knowing infraction.

As Courthouse News Service reports, because the number of users in Illinois that had uploaded photos of themselves to Facebook is in the millions, Donato expressed puzzlement as to why the charges weren’t in the tens of billions of dollars range.

“The Illinois Legislature said this is meant to be an expensive violation,” said Donato in a preliminary settlement approval hearing held via video.

He went on to demand an explanation as to why the higher range $5,000 penalty was taken off the table in light of a $5 billion fine Facebook paid the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) in 2019 for a violation involving the deception of users regarding how long their private information was under the social network giant’s control.

“It looks to me that what Facebook did to violate the BIPA may also have been a violation of that prior FTC consent decree, in which case you have a pretty good argument that this is an intentional or reckless violation of BIPA that would warrant $5,000,” Donato said.

The lawyer representing the plaintff class, Rafey Balabanian, argued that he felt the $47 billion maximum penalty was not realistic due to the fact that it appears Facebook was under the impression that the uploaded photographs were exempt from the BIPA, and had in fact lobbied for the Australian government to adopt the same definition of biometric information as is found in the BIPA legislation.

For his part, Donato said that he didn’t find that to be “a particularly persuasive argument,” and pointed out that the $550 million settlement amount would still only amount to 1.25% of the maximum if that number was in fact $47 billion.

“They’re taking what is essentially a 98.75% discount off what the Illinois Legislature said should be the damages,” Donato said.

Referring back to the ruling in the FTC case of last year, Donato also wanted both sides to explain how the BIPA stipulation that Facebook must delete plaintiff biometric data obtained without their consent is any different from what they were already required to do as a result of the FTC ruling.

“I want to hear more about why this is something that’s actually a benefit to the class and not just slapping on obligations that Facebook is already required to do,” he said, adding that he wants Facebook engineers to offer a plan for how they mean to handle the plaintiff’s facial data once the settlement is agreed upon.

For its part, Facebook is defending the technology used to obtain the face prints, arguing that it relies more on photographic elements like lighting than it does on facial geometry as the suit alleges.

Facebook attorney Michael Rhodes also stated his belief that the $550 million settlement — about $150 to $300 per person — is an “extraordinary economic recovery” for the class considering Facebook’s unwillingness to admit wrongdoing, and the fact that the plaintiffs suffered no “concrete harm” as a result of the violation – however, that argument was in fact rejected by a three-judge Ninth Circuit panel in August of 2019.

Donato has given both sides the next few weeks to come up with the answers he requested, warning them that a jury trial was still possible and the settlement was not a done deal should he remain unsatisfied with the reasoning behind the amount.

Source: Courthouse News Service

–

June 8, 2020 – by Tony Bitzionis

Related News

  • Facebook Biometric Privacy Case Settlement Do-over Gets Preliminary ApprovalFacebook Biometric Privacy Case Settlement Do-over Gets Preliminary Approval
  • Instagram Faces Class Action Lawsuit Under Illinois Biometrics LawInstagram Faces Class Action Lawsuit Under Illinois Biometrics Law
  • U.S Sens Sanders, Merkley Propose Nation-Wide BIPA LegislationU.S Sens Sanders, Merkley Propose Nation-Wide BIPA Legislation
  • Texas AG Investigates Facebook Over Biometric Privacy BreachTexas AG Investigates Facebook Over Biometric Privacy Breach
  • Facebook Returns with Increased Settlement in BIPA CaseFacebook Returns with Increased Settlement in BIPA Case
  • Federal Judge’s Biometric Information Privacy Act Dismissal Could Prove ConsequentialFederal Judge’s Biometric Information Privacy Act Dismissal Could Prove Consequential

Filed Under: Features, News Tagged With: Biometric, biometric data, biometric lawsuits, biometrics, BIPA, BIPA lawsuits, face biometrics, Facebook, facial recognition, Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act, Privacy, privacy issues

Primary Sidebar

Want To Deploy Biometric Access? Download This First:

The resources in this bundle will give you the know-how to choose the right biometric access for your organization.

Sponsored Links

facetec logo

FaceTec’s patented, industry-leading 3D Face Authentication software anchors digital identity, creating a chain of trust from user onboarding to ongoing authentication on all modern smart devices and webcams. FaceTec’s 3D FaceMaps™ make trusted, remote identity verification finally possible. As the only technology backed by a persistent spoof bounty program and NIST/iBeta Certified Liveness Detection, FaceTec is the global standard for Liveness and 3D Face Matching with millions of users on six continents in financial services, border security, transportation, blockchain, e-voting, social networks, online dating and more. www.facetec.com

TECH5 logo

TECH5 is an international technology company founded by experts from the biometrics industry, which focuses on developing disruptive biometric and digital ID solutions through the application of AI and Machine Learning technologies.

TECH5 target markets include both Government and Private sectors with products powering Civil ID, Digital ID, as well as authentication solutions that deliver identity assurance for various use cases. 

Learn more: www.tech5.ai

With its secunet border gears product portfolio and specialised consulting expertise, secunet supports police forces and security authorities in their sovereign tasks. Whether ABC gates, self-service kiosks or biometric middleware – each component helps to strengthen identity protection and to accelerate verification – in mobile and stationary scenarios.

Mobile ID World Logo

Mobile ID World is here to bring you the latest in mobile authentication solutions and application providers. Our company is dedicated to providing users with the best content and cutting edge information on technology, news, and mobile solutions for your mobile identity management needs.

Recent Posts

  • Facial Recognition in Policing, COVID Screening, and Consumer Tech: Identity News Digest
  • Police Biometrics, a Data Breach, and Card-focused Partnerships – Identity News Digest
  • Catch Up: The Latest Developments in Biometric Privacy Regulations
  • Highlighting Biometric Security, NC DMV Head Pushes for Mobile Driver’s License
  • NY Attorney General Takes Aim at Madison Square Garden: Identity News Digest

Biometric Associations

IBIA and fido

Tweets

Footer

  • About Us
  • Company Directory
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Archives
  • CCPA: Do not sell my personal info.

Follow Us

Copyright © 2023 FindBiometrics